How it works

This is the new gluten-free!

If you see something you'd like to order from us, your purchase needs to be made online through our website (where you are right now!) Once you purchase your goods, they will need to be picked up at our bakery in Elizabethtown, PA within 7 days. No need to call or make an appointment, pick up times can be found here.

The address for pick up is 1722 Bainbridge Rd., Elizabethtown. Or, you can just Google Map "Conoy Brethren in Christ Church." 

{We now offer Bakery Drops in both Dillsburg, PA and Reading, PA. If you'd like to be included in one of those drops, please e-mail me at or text me at 717-723-9494 for details.}

Once you arrive at the church during designated pick up times, the bakery is through the double blue doors towards the lower end. There will be signs to direct you.

All your items have been frozen for best quality. When you arrive, we will gather your order and hand it to you with a smile.

Best practices for thawing is always overnight in the refrigerator. We don't use any preservatives or nasty ingredients, so our products are best kept in the refrigerator or freezer. Thaw them as needed.

We can't wait to meet you and share our delicious baked goods!